Questions To Ask When Hiring A Recruiter

Great teams start with great interviews.

By recording live interviews, our platform harnesses the power of artificial intelligence to help teams run a faster, better interview process.

Request a Demo

Questions To Ask When Hiring A Recruiter

Hiring your first recruiter is like setting the groundwork for future growth. It's the foundation for all your future hires. Recruiters are key players in a fast-growing team - spotting, engaging, and assessing candidates for your critical roles - but there's more to it than that. A great recruiter will really "get" your organization- they'll see current gaps in the org charts, assess the needs of the team, and build a talent acquisition strategy to meet future demand proactively.

For all of these reasons and more, identifying the right recruiter for your team is a critical step in your growth- and it all starts with your preparation for the interview and the job interview questions you ask. Asking informative, inclusive, insightful interview questions that provoke responses that allow you to assess the recruiter candidate's experience, capabilities, and approach is key. Here are some of the best interview questions to ask when hiring a recruiter.

  1. Outside of using traditional job boards, what is your method for identifying top talent?

This question will give you insight into how the recruiter approaches finding and attracting candidates beyond just posting an open role, as well as their understanding of your organization's needs and requirements.

  1. Can you provide an example of a time when you had to source for a niche role? How did you go about finding potential candidates & what was your average time-to-hire?

This question will reveal the recruiter's experience in sourcing for difficult or specialized roles and their ability to meet tight timelines.

  1. Given that we're a rapidly growing organization, how would you plan strategic talent acquisition?

This question will highlight the recruiter's ability to think ahead and create a talent acquisition strategy that aligns with the company's growth goals.

  1. Can you walk me through your experience in using recruitment tools and technology?

Recruitment tools and technology are essential for efficient hiring processes. This question will help determine if the candidate is up-to-date with industry-standard tools and their proficiency with those tools.

  1. In your last role, how do you approach candidate engagement and communication?

This question will assess the recruiter's skills in building relationships with potential candidates and their ability to effectively communicate with them throughout the hiring process.

Keep in mind that job interview questions to ask candidates can vary dramatically based on your organization, industry, and needs. The best interview questions to ask candidates will align with each of those 3 factors and help you uncover the skills your interviewee brings to the table.

We have more than 1000 interview questions teed up to help you find the perfect recruiter for your team. With a few clicks, they can be added to our interview intelligence software to shorten interview prep times and deliver AI-powered insights to make better hiring decisions.

Questions To Ask When Hiring A Recruiter Interview

So let's go deeper into understanding a recruiter's approach, areas of expertise, natural skills, and previous experience. Let's use a hypothetical organization to illustrate this point. Imagine you're the CEO of a young pre-revenue SaaS startup that just closed its first round of funding - call it a seed round. You have a team of 6 people to build upon and soon a board of directors to report to. 

In this scenario, you need to hire a recruiter who can spot dedicated top talent and drive the company's growth. You want someone with experience in fast-paced environments, expertise in your industry, and the ability to build a strong team culture that aligns with your values. Here are some vital interview questions to ask when hiring a recruiter for this team:

  1. We're a rapidly growing company that'll be hiring more than a dozen roles next quarter, how do you plan to proactively source for these roles?

This question will assess the recruiter's ability to handle high-volume hiring and their strategic approach to finding top talent.

  1. Tell me about a time when you had to balance multiple priorities while juggling a high number of open roles. How did you handle it?

This question will reveal the recruiter's multitasking skills (which they'll need in a fast-paced startup environment) and their ability to prioritize and manage their workload effectively.

  1. How have you leveraged your industry knowledge to identify top talent in previous roles?

This question will showcase the recruiter's expertise in your specific industry and how they can use that knowledge to find the right candidates for your team.

  1. From the opposite perspective, how would you approach hiring roles where you don't have specific knowledge?

Startup teams often require hiring for roles that may not fit the traditional mold. This question will help assess the recruiter's adaptability and openness to new ideas and approaches.

  1. Can you walk me through your experience with diversity and inclusion in recruitment?

Building a diverse and inclusive team is crucial for any organization's success, and this question will assess the recruiter's experience and commitment to diversity and inclusion in their hiring practices.

Overall, these questions aim to uncover the recruiter's previous experiences dealing with fast-paced environments, high-volume hiring, industry knowledge and expertise, adaptability, and commitment to diversity and inclusion. These questions to ask when hiring a recruiter in the interview showcase some of our priorities and the semi-structured nature that we prefer in interviews, but know that these questions are structured to uncover the candidate's skills and experience beyond what you'd see on a resume.

If you'd like an additional tool to help you assess recruiter candidates give Pillar a try. With a suite of interview intelligence solutions powered by AI, you can streamline your hiring process with data-driven insights to build your dream team.

Questions To Ask A Recruiter During An Interview

Now that we've gone deeper into a candidate's relevant experience, let's talk about culture fit, values, and compatibility. What are good questions to ask when hiring a recruiter and identifying if they're a good fit or not?

Assessing a recruiter's fit and compatibility with your organization is crucial to building an effective partnership. Using our previous pre-revenue SaaS startup as an example, let's create a decision matrix to assess a candidate at two key points in the hiring process, the phone screen and the first interview. On the phone screen, you're deciding if the candidate has the basic qualifications necessary to move forward to the hiring manager (in this case the CEO) interview, and after the first interview you have to decide whether this candidate is a potential fit or not.

Questions to ask a recruiter during the phone screen:

  1. Can you briefly describe your recruiting experience and the type of roles you’ve filled?
  2. How familiar are you with SaaS, our product, and the types of roles we’re looking to fill?
  3. What recruiting tools and software are you proficient in using?
  4. Have you ever managed a recruitment pipeline for a rapidly growing company?
  5. What strategies do you employ to ensure a diverse candidate pool?
  6. How do you stay updated with the latest trends in recruitment?
  7. What motivates you to work in recruitment, and specifically, why are you interested in working with our company?

If their answers are satisfactory and they move on to the first interview, here are some questions to ask a recruiter during the interview:

  1. Can you tell me about a time when you had to overcome a difficult hiring challenge? How did you handle it?
  2. How do you prioritize and manage your workload in a fast-paced environment with multiple open roles?
  3. What are some ways that you have leveraged technology to improve your recruitment process?
  4. Tell me about a time when you had to make a tough decision regarding a potential candidate. How did you handle it?
  5. How do you maintain and foster relationships with candidates even after the hiring process is over?
  6. In your experience, what has been the most effective way to assess a candidate's cultural fit within an organization?
  7. What have you learned from past recruitment experiences that have helped shape your approach and honed your skills?

To reiterate, these recruiter interview questions are going to be a bit more generic than some of yours will be because they need to fit a broad range of employers in varied industries. However, hopefully, they'll serve as a good starting point. You can tailor and customize them to fit your needs.

In conclusion, remember that interview questions are only half the equation. Actively listening to a candidate's responses and asking follow-up questions to dig deeper and uncover their critical thinking processes and decision-making skills are equally important. Remember, a successful recruitment process is a two-way street that depends on clear communication, mutual respect, and a shared vision for what your team can achieve together.

If you're hiring your first recruiter or struggling to find the right one, book your demo of Pillar today. We'd love to show you how our interview intelligence tools can help you make data-driven hiring decisions and build an incredible team. Happy Hiring!