Way more than just video interviews.
Our interview intelligence guides you through the entire interview process, so you find your next great teammate—effectively and equitably.
“Having the ability to record and share interview clips with our hiring teams has been a game-changer in getting good candidates into the process and speeding up our time to hire.”
“Pillar is a huge opportunity for us to be completely confident about the fairness and effectiveness of our assessments. It is an invaluable tool for coaching, developing and supporting our newer interviewers on the team.”
Interviewing a candidate can be tedious. The tedium is exacerbated when you have to have to interview half a dozen candidates back to back. This is why it's important to do a candidate assessment immediately after the interview. Assessing a candidate after the interview can provide valuable insights that may be lost if you wait until later in the day. It also helps to consolidate your thoughts and impressions while they are still fresh in your mind.
This assessment doesn't have to be comprehensive or lengthy, but it should highlight the key strengths and weaknesses of the candidate. It's also important to provide specific examples from their interview to support your assessment.
Interview as an Assessment Tool:
Before we dive into the tips and sample comments, let's discuss why the interview itself is an important assessment tool. During the interview, you can assess various skills and qualities such as communication, problem-solving, and teamwork. It also allows you to gauge a candidate's potential cultural fit within the company.
Additionally, interviewing allows for a two-way exchange of information. Not only are you assessing the candidate, but they are also assessing the company. This can provide valuable insights into their level of interest and motivation for the role.
Tips for Assessing After the Interview:
Now that we've established the importance of assessing after the interview, let's discuss some tips to keep in mind while conducting your assessment:
1. Take notes during the interview: This may seem obvious, but taking notes during the interview will help you remember key details and examples to include in your assessment.
2. Use a scoring system: Consider developing a scoring system beforehand to help quantify your assessment. This can make it easier to compare candidates objectively.
3. Focus on specific skills and qualities: Tailor your assessment toward the specific skills and qualities required for the role. This will help you provide more targeted feedback and evaluation.
4. Provide examples: Use specific examples from the candidate's interview to support your assessment. This will help make it more concrete and provide evidence for your evaluation.
5. Be honest but constructive: When providing feedback, be honest about both strengths and weaknesses, but also offer constructive criticism on how they can improve.
Assessment (after the interview) Sample Comments:
Here are some sample comments you can use when providing feedback to HR after conducting an interview:
- "Candidate A demonstrated strong communication skills during the interview. They were able to articulate their experiences and qualifications with confidence and clarity."
- "While Candidate B had limited experience in problem-solving, they showed a willingness to learn and adapt, which could make them a valuable asset to the team."
- "I was impressed by Candidate C's teamwork abilities. They gave examples of successfully collaborating with their previous team and showed a positive attitude towards working with others."
- "Candidate D had all the necessary qualifications for the role, but their lack of enthusiasm and motivation during the interview was concerning."
These sample comments are just a few examples to give you an idea of how to structure your assessment feedback. Remember to be specific, and honest, and provide examples to support your assessment. This will help HR make informed decisions when selecting the best candidate for the role.
If you're looking for more resources on after-interview assessments and candidate scoring, check out our interview intelligence software. At Pillar, we have objective scoring systems and customizable assessments to help you select the best candidate for your company.
Assessments after interviews are more like a summary of the strengths and weaknesses or gaps a candidate may have. Assessment interview examples and feedback could look like this: "Out of the 10 categories we assessed the candidate upon, 8 were 10 out of 10, and 2 were 9 out of 10. We believe that this candidate is a great fit for the role." This feedback shows that the candidate performed exceptionally well in most areas and may be a strong contender for the position.
On the other hand, an assessment after an interview could also reveal some red flags or areas of improvement for a candidate. For example: "While the candidate has excellent qualifications and experience, their communication skills seemed lacking during the interview. This may be a concern for the role, which requires strong communication skills." This feedback highlights a specific area where the candidate needs to improve and provides HR with valuable information when making their decision.
Interview feedback to HR is a vital function in the hiring process, as it helps HR understand how each candidate performed and what their strengths and weaknesses are. The two interview feedback to HR examples we gave provide a glimpse into the different ways assessments can be conducted and how they can vary depending on the candidate's performance.
Other factors to consider when providing feedback to HR include the candidate's demeanor, body language, and overall impression. These non-verbal cues can also give valuable insights into a candidate's personality and potential cultural fit within the company.
When providing interview feedback to HR, it is also essential to keep in mind the overall goal of the assessment: finding the best candidate for the role. This means that your feedback should be objective and based on specific criteria, rather than personal opinions or biases.
Pillar's interview intelligence software, scoring systems, and interviewer coaching were created with objectivity in mind- Eliminating biases and ensuring a fair assessment of all candidates is crucial in creating a diverse and inclusive workplace.
Interview assessments are not only crucial for HR to make informed decisions but also an opportunity for candidates to receive valuable feedback on their performance. These points of candidate feedback in the interview process are essential for their professional development and growth. Here are some sample positive interview feedback to HR that you can use when providing your assessment:
- "Candidate A was well-prepared for the interview, and their enthusiasm for the role was evident. They provided thorough answers to our questions, and I believe they would make a valuable addition to the team."
- "I was impressed by Candidate B's technical skills and their ability to solve complex problems. They showed a strong understanding of the industry and were able to articulate how their experience aligns with our company's goals."
- "Candidate C displayed excellent time management during the interview, efficiently answering all questions within the allocated timeframe. Their organizational skills would be an asset in our fast-paced environment."
- "I appreciate Candidate D's eagerness to learn and their willingness to take on new challenges. Their passion for the industry was evident, and I believe they have the potential to excel in this role."
These positive assessment comments not only highlight a candidate's strengths but also provide specific examples of their performance during the interview.
However, it is equally important to provide constructive criticism when necessary. Here are some sample interview assessment comments that can be used to address areas of improvement:
- "While Candidate A has relevant experience and qualifications, their answers lacked detail and examples. I would recommend encouraging them to provide more specific responses in future interviews."
- "Candidate B had great technical skills, but they seemed nervous during the interview, which affected their communication. I suggest providing them with more opportunities to practice and build their confidence."
- "During the interview, Candidate C struggled to give concrete examples of their problem-solving abilities. I believe they would benefit from some additional training in this area."
- "Although Candidate D has great potential, their lack of team player attitude may be a concern for our company culture. It would be beneficial to have further discussions with them about working in a team environment."
Remember to provide specific examples and actionable suggestions when giving feedback to HR. These and other technical interview feedback examples will not only help the candidate improve and hopefully shore up their interviewing skills in the future, but also assist HR in making their final decision.
A "post-interview" assessment, meaning an assessment conducted after an interview, is a crucial step in the hiring process. We've already talked about it in the previous sections so I won't belabor the point here, but it's a method of evaluating a candidate's performance and providing feedback to HR for their consideration.
This post-interview (meaning "after") assessment can take various forms, such as scoring systems, interviewer notes, or interview intelligence software that automatically records, highlights, and shares relevant aspects of the candidate's experience with other members of the team. The purpose remains the same: to gather objective information about the candidate's skills, experience, and fit for the role.
Post-interview assessments are not only beneficial for HR but also for the candidate. They provide a chance to receive valuable feedback and insights into their performance, which can help them improve in future interviews. It's an opportunity for candidates to learn from their mistakes and showcase their strengths.
In conclusion, conducting assessments after an interview and providing feedback to HR is a crucial step in finding the best candidate for the role. It helps eliminate biases, ensures a fair evaluation process, and provides valuable insights for both the HR team and candidates. Remember to use specific examples and objective criteria when giving feedback and always keep the overall goal in mind: finding the right fit for your company.
If you're currently seeing higher than-normal attrition rates and you'd like to lower employee turnover, book your demo of Pillar today. We'd love to show you how we've helped our customers lower employee turnover by 50% in the last 12 months.